James Monroe Fay, b. 23 Mar 1847 in Chester, Hampden County, Massachusetts, d. 1921 in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts, son of Warren Fay & Jane D. Bell. He married Harriette Forsyth (1st wife) on May 10, 1871 in Northampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts. He married Mary L. Hubbard (2nd wife) on March 23, 1887 in Hatfield, Hampshire County, Massachusetts. He married Clara Matilda Cate (3rd wife).
John Sawyer Fay, b. 15 Jan 1840 in Berlin, Worcester County, Massachusetts, d. 15 Feb 1914 in Marlborough, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, son of Samuel Chandler Fay & Nancy Warren. He married S. Elizabeth "Lizzie" Ingalls (1st wife) on November 20, 1869 in Marlborough, Middlesex County, Massachusetts. He married Mary M. Wilder (2nd wife) on August 21, 1911 in Lewiston, Androscoggin County, Maine.
Jonathan Ward Fay, b. 25 Apr 1801 in Athol, Worcester County, Massachusetts, d. 6 May 1892 in Athol, Worcester County, Massachusetts, son of Josiah Fay & Molly Ward. He married Mary L. Babbitt on September 11, 1828 in Petersham, Worcester County, Massachusetts.