Charles H. Gardner, b. 19 Feb 1838 near Duncansville, Blair County, Pennsylvania, d. 19 Oct 1920 in Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, son of Robert Gardner & Rebecca Hartsock. He married Emily H. Smith (1st wife) on July 14, 1869 in Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania. He married Irene F. Smith (2nd wife) on September 13, 1895 in Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania.
Charles Le Fevre Gardner, b. 27 May 1839 in Cummington, Hampshire County, Massachusetts, d. 20 Mar 1913 in Springfield, Hampden County, Massachusetts, son of Elisha Gardner & Elvira Sprague. He married Esther Ely Gilmore on May 19, 1869 in Monson, Hampden County, Massachusetts.
Charles Spurgeon Gardner, b. 28 Feb 1859 in Gibson County, Tennessee, d. 3 Apr 1948 in Louisville, Jefferson County, Kentucky, son of Stephen Eddy Gardner & Eveline Ellen Wood. He married Ariadne Turner (1st wife) on April 17, 1884 in Haywood County, Tennessee. He married Mary Carter Anderson (2nd wife) on September 1, 1920 in Richmond, Virginia.
Charles William Gardner, b. 17 Feb 1861 in New York, d. 12 Nov 1940 in Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara County, California, son of Unknown Gardner & Unknown Mills. He married Helen M. Connolly on April 6, 1882 in Minneapolis, Hennepin County, Minnesota.