James Hay, b. 9 Jan 1856 in Millwood, Clarke County, Virginia, d. 12 Jun 1931 in Madison, Madison County, Virginia, son of William Hay & Emily Lewis. He married Constance Tatum (1st wife) on October 1, 1878 in Rockingham County, Virginia. He married Frances B. Gordon (2nd wife) on June 9, 1891 in Richmond, Virginia.
John Breese Hay, b. 8 Jan 1834 in Belleville, St. Clair County, Illinois, d. 29 Jun 1916 in Winnetka, Cook County, Illinois, son of Andrew Hay &Unknown.
John Milton Hay, b. 8 Oct 1838 in Salem, Washington County, Indiana, d. 1 Jul 1905 in Newbury, Merrimack County, New Hampshire, son of Charles Hay & Helen Leonard. He married Clara L. Stone on February 4, 1874 in Cuyahoga County, Ohio.